The Oregon Natural Resources Report - Agricultural News from Oregon

Circuit court lets McNair Decision stand

September 23, 2008

By American Forest Research Council
AFRC News, 9/16.

On September 11, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals denied a request to reverse its decision on the Mission Brush case (Lands Council v McNair). The plaintiffs had asked for a full court review of the decision, following the court’s unanimous en banc ruling by 11 judges. The court
denied their request because not a single judge voted in favor of a review. The en banc decision
is significant not only because the court reversed its own earlier rulings, but established a limited
judicial framework for review of agency decisions. It also dictates that substantial deference be
given to the Forest Service’s own decision making process; clarifies that NFMA contain no
requirement for on the ground analysis; and recognizes that the Forest Service must balance
competing demands in managing the national forests, so that wildlife viability is not the only

In deciding whether to grant a request for an injunction, judges must now balance
harm to the environment against other harms, such as wildfire or economic losses.

On August 22, Joel Holtrop, National Forest Deputy Chief for National Forest System, issued a
memo to Regional Foresters and other personnel noting the decision will enable the agency to
more effectively manage our national forests and grasslands. /Ann Forest Burns

### There is much more to read in the AFRC News click here.

Print This Post Print This Post    Email This Post Email This Post

Discuss this article

Go Jo September 23, 2008

If this is a strike for balance as it seems, it is long overdue.

Rex T. September 23, 2008

Economic impact must be a part of any environmental regulation. Oregon’s natural resource economy has suffered because of too many rules with no accountability. The people making the rules are too far away from the people being laid off because of them. We need to put the human factor back into the enviromental equation.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Please answer the following question to confirm that you are a real person: *

Natural Resource Headlines

Top Business News


Top Natural Resource News


Top Faith News


Copyright © 2019, OregonReport. All Rights Reserved. | Terms of Use - Copyright - Legal Policy | Contact Oregon Report

--> --> -->